Thursday, February 17, 2005

The Apocalyptic Landscape

Over at Peak Energy, Monkeygrinder has an excellent and sobering post on the need to strike a balance between realistic pessimism and realistic hopefulness, without falling prey to the lures and snares of terriblisma on the one hand, and complacent optimism on the other.

I've been thinking about the questions he raises for a couple of days now. I have no solutions, but I do have lots of disorganized and probably irrational thoughts. (What a shock, eh?)

The painting above, since you asked, is called Apokalyptische Landschaft. It was painted by Ludwig Meidner, way back in 1912. Meidner's era, like ours, aestheticized catastrophe to a remarkable extent, and Meidner was one of those melancholic artists who saw destruction as horrible but necessary, given the degraded state of the world. His contemporaries in the Italian Futurist movement, by contrast, called war "the world's only hygiene" and celebrated the idea of destruction as a noble goal in and of itself. To them, destruction was not merely punitive or cathartic, but something more akin to a spiritual duty.

In this dichotomy, I think we can see hints of today's divide between the devotées of terriblisma on the Left and Right: very generally speaking, left-wing melancholics tend to feel that destruction will punish or cleanse them, while right-wing militants believe that being agents of destruction will exalt them. Both hopes, I suspect, come from a similar dissatisfaction with a way of life that lacks meaning. Both groups, though they turn their weariness with the status quo in radically different directions, are basically saying "If the world must end, let's get it over with; the suspense is killing me." (And they're right, is killing them. We might - with a nod to the irritating crypto-teleological sophistry of Richard Dawkins - call an organism in this state "Something Eager to Die.")

I assume that anyone who's reading this doesn't want the world to be violently, gruesomely transformed a la Meidner or the Futurists, no matter how likely or even inescapable that fate might seem. In this regard, Rorschach has aptly quoted Gramsci's call for "pessimism of the intellect, and optimism of the will." And as a personal stance, that's pretty close to ideal in my book (though the intellect does have a knack for undercutting the will, as I know all too well).

As a public, rhetorical stance, though, I'm afraid it's insufficient, and possibly counterproductive. There's a real longing for upheaval and catastrophe in some quarters, and horror stories about the future - even if they're intended to shock people into awareness - may amount to little more than fuel for that fire. Fortunately, there's more to people and societies than the urge to punish and be punished, to kill and be killed; if there's hope for us, I believe it lies in disavowing pessimism, catering to healthier societal urges, and turning unhealthy urges in more constructive directions.

I argued a few months ago that powerlessness corrupts, and I really feel this is a truth that can't be overstated. To the extent that we encourage a sense of powerlessness, we push people towards the emotional adaptation of aestheticizing or spirtualizing or otherwise justifying disaster. It may even be that the current epidemic of gleefully destructive moral nihilism on the Right is partially a response to the warnings of impending ecological or nuclear disaster promulgated by the Left in decades past. Who knows? At any rate, it seems obvious that Americans do feel powerless. They're looking for something to fill this void...and when they can't beat it, they join it.

In answer to Monkeygrinder's question, I don't know what might "save" us from the problem of peak oil (or any other looming disaster). But I do know we need a strong public demand for progress, and a general willingness to make sacrifices. We have thousands of people in this country who were willing to give up their own lives, or the lives of their sons and daughters, for Bush's cruel hoax of a war. If that degree of commitment could be refocused on something useful, much smaller sacrifices could have much more positive results.

Therefore, I think the main issue here is one of framing. The Right needs to be seen by the popular mind as a group of people who stand in the way of something new and exciting. We need to convince people that there's a brighter, more interesting world right around the corner, and that the main thing keeping us from reaching it is a relatively small group of greedy people who lack vision and wisdom.

Of course, we might not find a technological fix for our energy problems. But the more years we can squeeze out of whatever oil's left, the better our chances are. In my opinion, the chance that we'll solve at least part of the energy problem in the next twenty years is far better than the chance that we'll have a working space-based missile defense program in the next fifty.

Therefore, we need to encourage conservation. But does this mean we need to advocate it on the basis of an apocalyptic peak-oil scenario? I don't think so...or at least, not always. The one-issue mindset limits our ability to be effective advocates for change. There are other, more effective types of leverage than fear of calamitous social breakdown...especially when so many people dislike the society we've got, and may have a secret wish to watch it collapse.

On the Left, we tend to focus on issues that we feel should be of interest to responsible adults. But America is not entirely a nation of responsible adults. There's nothing wrong with pointing out, on occasion, that BushCo is denying us not just clean air and water, but more fun and better toys.

The Right has had a lot of success painting us as puritanical killjoys. But all you have to do is look at sites like Treehugger, Metaefficient, Boing Boing, and Near Near Future to see that, in fact, it's the cheap-labor, anti-competition, scaremongering blowhards of the Right who are the real killjoys. They're not just enemies of biodiversity; they're also enemies of technological and scientific diversity, and they're robbing us of all sorts of interesting and attractive products and possibilities.

There are other forms of leverage, too. The epidemic of obesity among the working population, which costs employers a fortune, could conceivably be used as justification for redesigning residential areas or workplaces in ways that would, coincidentally, reduce dependence on automobiles. For instance, employees who bicycle to work might receive, say, 20 minutes of vacation time per day. In a year, they'd earn an extra two weeks of vacation time. The incentive here has nothing to do with peak oil, but it has a real effect, however modest, on both conservation and air quality.

As I said, these are very disorganized thoughts. But I do think that if we can't come up with a miraculous solution like cold fusion, we need an innovation economy that produces lots of little solutions, and promotes cooperation between experts - and amateurs - in many different fields. Meanwhile, on the rhetorical level, we need to give people hope, and a personal stake in seeing the world change. If a certain amount of apocalyptic thinking comes from emotional dissatisfaction with what passes for life in these United States, then we need to make people eager for a more wholesome form of "regeneration" than fascism offers. As it stands now, I'm afraid that apocalyptic scenarios are simply too emotionally attractive to have any reliable transformative power. As odd as it sounds, we're simply going to have to offer people something a bit more fulfilling than the end of the world.


Speechless said...

Phila, inspite of your concern that this was disorganized, I found this posting really clear and provactive. I love the way you brought together the two ends of the political spectrum here. And it makes sense, ultimately there are issues where we share common ground with the average right winger. It makes sense to focus on the stuff we can fix.

In Philadelphia our Public Transit system is almost broke, our roads are clogged with cars and, while the buses are used in the inner city, it's very expensive. The trains are used by the suburbanites cause the poor folks can't afford to take the train 'cause the fare is so high. What we have, essentially, is public transportation segregated by class.
I've started wondering why we don't have FREE public transportation. We could pay for it with taxes on people who drive private cars. Soon we'd all be on the buses and people wouldn't feel stigmatized or afraid to take the bus as they do now.

dread pirate roberts said...

i try to not obsess about impending doom, but i have thought for many years that our financial structure must collapse any day; that in spite of medical wonders some new plague will certainly find advantage in overcrowded cities; that geological processes have not stopped and the tectonic plates are still grinding against each other. that's all intellectual, though i prefer to call it realism rather than pessimism. shows how wrong i can be.

as i live day to day fairly cheerfully, tho not so much lately in view of national policy, i suppose i have optimism of will. i think you're onto something big and important with that idea of more fun and better toys. apocalyptic scenarios can only, it seems to me, have transformative power in a negative sense: change or die. a positive vision of possibilities certainly spurs me to action more than does fear. i seem to recall we used to call it the "reactionary right" and got it to stick. liberalism was hopeful of a brighter future.

dread pirate roberts

Rmj said...

There's a real longing for upheaval and catastrophe in some quarters, and horror stories about the future - even if they're intended to shock people into awareness - may amount to little more than fuel for that fire. I don't have time to review this post and give it the consideration it deserves, but I wanted to note that this is as succinct and apt a description of apocalyptic literature and philosophy as I have seen.

"Apocalyptic" not only predicts a cataclysmic change in the status quo, but embraces it, and even seeks to "make it so."

monkeygrinder said...

Good stuff.

Peak Energy has as reasonable outcomes many doomsday scenarios. It is an apocalyptic fugue.

This conversation has clarified for me that I've got to write, and live with these scenarios in the same way I deal with my own mortality, (that personal doomsday, death.)

Humor, common sense, enjoy the moment to the fullest, live.

Phila said...


That's actually something I meant to work in. We're not guaranteed a future, individually or en masse, no matter how much cheap energy we find. But we're obliged to go about our business all the same, and we may as well enjoy it if we can.

Anonymous said...

For several weeks I was driving myself crazy with the impending disastrous consequences of previous generations. The information or misinformation out there can be very overwhelming. I came to the conclusion that I would not wait for the government or the corporatocracy to step in and save the day (because it isnt going to happen) and not let fear cloud my ability to make sound decisions. I have chosen to alter my direct spheres of influence using logic and rationality to guide decision making. By focusing positive energy (instead of calculating the effects of negative doomsday scenarios) I would begin by softening the blow of any possible collapse. I began by preparing my home and my way of life. I then began informing friends and family of the possible scenarios that are unfolding just beneath the surface of media created American reality. This has been somewhat difficult and at times akward, with a large part just thinking that I am crazy. My conscious is clear I have given them information it is up to them to accept this information or not. I have decided to run for an elected position in the city and possibly the state. I figure that I can influence policy by making self sustainablity a part of the discussion. Many cities and states are facing budget shortfalls these eco-friendly and sustainable practices would save money or generate income for the cities or states. When people think that they are powerless they propagate the feeling, which in turn reinforces this abstract idea eventually making it not an abstract idea but reality.

Atkins said...

You can find some great information about stromberg 97 air cleaners right here in case anyone is interested.

Anonymous said...

This painting depicts an eerie preview of the last days. I would like to share its meaning with you as the Bible makes it clear.

We are presently studying the book of Revelation in the Holy Bible. Chapter 18 tells about the "Fall of Babylon". Babylon has two meanings: 1)a False system of worship that will dominate the future one-world government (ultimately destroyed by the Antichrist) and 2)City where the evil spirit dwells. This is the city in the painting. It will be a great city (Verse 2). It will be a hideout of demons and evil spirits (Verse 2). Her sins will be piled as high as heaven (V.5). The tower of Babel written about in Genesis Chapter 11 was built by men in that day as a monument to their greatness. It was a great tower, which reached to the skies. Babylon represents man's pride, selfishness and no need for God. This attitude truly defies God.

In Verse 4, John heard a voice from heaven calling "Come away from her, my people. Do not take part in her sins, or you will be punished with her". There are two people fleeing the city in the painting, one looks like a man and the other appears to be smaller, perhaps a woman.

God will judge Babylon because He is a just and holy God. He is without sin, and cannot deny Himself. Verse 8 says "that Babylon will utterly be consumed by fire". The fire in the painting looks like it is coming from heaven.

My opinion: The stage is currently being set for all of this to take place in the future. Satan's strategies are at work in this world and we cannot underestimate his power. There is hope if we trust in our Lord Jesus' promises. I am glad for His spiritual protection though I may be physically harmed. It is my prayer and hope that all who read this comment are as well. God Bless and thank you for giving me the oppurtunity to share.

Anonymous said...

warhammer gold warhammer money warhammer accounts tibia money tibia gold tibia item runescape accounts buy runescape accounts runescape money runescape gold runescape gp runescape power leveling runescape powerleveling cheap rs2 powerleveling runescape equipment buy rs equipment runescape runes cheap rs2 runes runescape logs cheap rs2 logs runescape items buy runescape items runescape quest point rs2 quest point cheap runescape questpoint runescape gold runescape items runescape power leveling runescape money runescape gold buy runescape gold buy runescape money runescape items runescape accounts runescape gp runescape accounts runescape money runescape power leveling runescape powerleveling tibia gold dofus kamas buy dofus kamas wow power leveling wow powerleveling runescape questpoint rs2 questpoint Warcraft PowerLeveling Warcraft Power Leveling World of Warcraft PowerLeveling World of Warcraft Power Leveling Hellgate money Hellgate gold buy runescape logs buy rs2 items cheap runescape items Hellgate London gold Guild Wars Gold buy Guild Wars Gold runescape items rs2 accounts cheap rs2 equipments lotro gold buy lotro gold buy runescape money buy runescape gold buy runescape runes lotro gold buy lotro gold runescape money runescape gold cheap rs2 powerleveling eve isk eve online isk buy runescape power leveling rs2 power leveling tibia gold tibia item runescape accounts Fiesta Silver Fiesta Gold Scions of Fate Gold Hellgate Palladium Hellgate London Palladium SOF Gold Age Of Conan Gold AOC Gold ArchLord gold tibia money tibia gold runescape accounts runescape gold cheap rs2 powerleveling buy ArchLord gold DDO Plat Dungeons and Dragons Online Plat


runescape money runescape gold runescape money buy runescape gold buy runescape money runescape money runescape gold wow power leveling wow powerleveling Warcraft Power Leveling Warcraft PowerLeveling buy runescape gold buy runescape money runescape itemsrunescape accounts runescape gp dofus kamas buy dofus kamas Guild Wars Gold buy Guild Wars Gold lotro gold buy lotro gold lotro gold buy lotro gold lotro gold buy lotro gold runescape money runescape power leveling runescape money runescape gold dofus kamas cheap runescape money cheap runescape gold Hellgate Palladium Hellgate London Palladium Hellgate money Tabula Rasa gold tabula rasa money Tabula Rasa Credit Tabula Rasa Credits Hellgate gold Hellgate London gold wow power leveling wow powerleveling Warcraft PowerLeveling Warcraft Power Leveling World of Warcraft PowerLeveling World of Warcraft Power Leveling runescape power leveling runescape powerleveling eve isk eve online isk eve isk eve online isk tibia gold Fiesta Silver Fiesta Gold
Age of Conan Gold
buy Age of Conan Gold
aoc gold

china tour
beijing tour
beijing travel
china tour
tibet tour
tibet travel
computer monitoring software
employee monitoring