Friday, December 24, 2004

No Child Left Behind

The most pressing problems we're likely to face in the coming decades are not military, but technological. Energy independence, disease management, waste management, pollution control and site remediation, urban planning, global warming, effective counterterrorism...all of these things require technological and behavioral responses, and thus depend on our ability to educate citizens to meet these challenges.

Many EU countries are pulling ahead of us on these fronts. And because they really do make educating all their children a priority, that trend is likely to continue. Consider this article on Finland:

Finland spends more per elementary, middle- and high- school student than any other nation on Earth, and comes in second on spending for higher education. School lunches, health care, most class materials and university tuition are all free....Schools are local, community-based affairs, with extremely low turnover in their teaching staffs and strong expectations on parents. Students are all expected to study languages, math and science (and in Finland, girls now outperform boys on science tests). Two thirds of them go to university.
How ciuld anyone read that and feel proud of this country's current priorities? While Finland helps its female children to excel in the sciences, we're warning young girls that they'll be sexually undesirable if they "threaten a man's confidence" by knowing things. Which culture is going to be stronger and more secure in coming years? And which will be safer from tyranny?

We're not just wasting young lives in Iraq; we're wasting them every time we allow the anti-intellectual zealots of the Republican party to limit the educational options of our nation's children.


filkertom said...

Heh. Reminds me of a quote from A Civil Campaign by Bujold: "Women are wasted here. All the women are wasted here."

I really believe that some people in our government read 1984 and Brave New World and thought, "Training manuals". They seem to be determined to create Beta, Delta, Gamma, and Epsilon castes.

Wyatt Junker said...


You boys are a riot!

A Quiet Riot that is.

echidne said...

Finland takes education seriously. One of the things that article doesn't mention, and which I happen to know, because I have a very good Finnish friend, is this:

Teachers are paid as well as engineers.

Think about that and what its effects are.

Sue123 said...
Feel free to take this all purpose test designed for legislators, parents, teachers, students, and readers to test their knowledge about NCLB and U.S. education policy, complete with sources and footnotes.